All good things must end, said Reid Anderson last Thursday night towards the end of the Bad Plus’s set at LPR. But why. Why deprive the world of THIS?! This being some of the most exciting 90 minutes of live music I’ve heard in a hot sec.
I think I first became a Bad Plus fan in early 2017 following a jazz world – controversy – in which Robert Glasper and Ethan Iverson were caught being…pretty awful. Iverson at the time played piano in the Bad Plus, alongside Dave King on drums and Reid Anderson on bass. Iverson also kept a jazz blog, Do the Math. In an interview with Robert Glasper, the two ended up traveling down a rabbit hole basically about how women don’t like soloing in jazz and just want to groove. And reference is made to “musical clitoris.” The interview, of course, came out on International Women’s Day. It sparked outrage and annoyance in jazz’s little corner of the world. I read it. Didn’t love it! But ngl did want to know more about this band’s allegedly excellent groove…
I loved them. Of course, their versions of popular songs like smells like teen spirit and everybody wants to rule the world are a blast. I became particularly obsessed with the band’s recently released album It’s Hard. I love the Beautiful Ones a lot. Just lovely – perfect, really. It’s a really sweet, mellow melody, and the drums + bass just kind of vibing over it in a way I love. There are some fun twists and turns in it too.
I also began watching Dave King’s YouTube show Rational Funk which is hilarious. He’s nicer than Ethan Iverson – a very funny, cool dude, and truly one of the most incredible drummers. Likely my fave along with Brian Blade. Tangentially, I have seen him play a fair bit with Julian Lage (featured prominently on this blog). He’s my favorite drummer to see with Julian. Brings out his weirder side (my favorite side) (same as Nels Cline does when they play together). I also love his tattoos.
Not long after the musical clitoris drama, I was lucky enough to see the Bad Plus at the vanguard with the one and only Bill Frisell. Honestly, that was a long time ago and memory is fuzzy, but I am sure it was killing. Subsequently, I got to see the iteration of the band featuring Orrin Evans on piano (goodbye Ethan). I am fairly sure I also went to a show where they had a horn player…but I forget.

I haven’t been closely following what they’ve been up to the last two-ish years, but it turns out the band has evolved again! No more piano. Add guitar (Ben Monder) and tenor sax (Chris Speed). Exceptional additions, as it turns out.
Luckily, I tuned back in just in time to get tickets to the Stop tour, the band’s alleged farewell jaunt. My friend Alex and I braved a torrential storm and crazy winds to get to Le Poisson Rouge. The band performed in the round which was cool. And the show was sold out – a truly packed house and absolutely excellent crowd. Folks were locked in and rocking out all night. Alex and I were standing behind Ben Monder (Alex came into the night a big fan. I had listened some but was less in the know.). This ended up being an amusing experience. Ben added an exciting element of Big Noise to the band. Beautiful overtones and under the sea sounding guitar. There were multiple times where we acknowledged that we would have been curious to actually see what he was doing. Alas, the mystery was entertaining. At the end of the night, we went up to check out his pedalboard. He did a lot with not a whole lot!

I really loved the compositions they played. I think my favorites were French horns, not even close to far off, and motivations II. The band was very tight and these are complicated tunes, but it all felt very spontaneous and inspired. They played all originals (I believe). Since the show, I have been listening to their 2022 and 2024 albums nonstop. Both are wonderful. Different from previous – more modern and no longer doing the pop/rock songs.
There were a few genuinely transcendent moments where the band all came together on the same chord. And, throughout, Dave King is just straight fire. His drumming is so expressive – not so much drum fills as lyrical lines. It feels almost like the best rap. His set also sounded beautiful and unique. Huge, hollow, awesome bass drum. Rich and full toms, and, obviously, a beautiful snare sound. We noticed, too, that they had him mic’d up big time. Mics above and below the snare and hi hats as well as all the usual places. His hi hats sounded better and more exciting to me than any I have heard ever. He also seems to use them more (and his ride a bit less) than most jazz drummers. Interesting and cool. We both agreed we want to play drums.
On our way out of the venue we noticed the massive line at the merch table. A line that did not exist before the show. And jazz show merch generally seems to be less of a thing than same for rock bands…Evidently a good number of folks were convinced by the show that they needed a momento. Alex and I were pleased that we’d already gone all in on t-shirts.
It’s cool that the Bad Plus as a band is in fact the rhythm section. Dave King and Reid Anderson truly do sound spectacular together – the kind of locked in that happens when you’ve been playing with someone since age 15, I suppose. The idea of them not continuing to make music together when it’s this good is sad. But it was good while it lasted, and I am excited to see what they both get up to next. I shall be listening!
ALEX TRIPP GUEST POST:
What Lena said!
Also: This was a real “listen with your eyes”-type concert. Anderson and King are both such dynamic performers that the listening experience is inextricable from their little gestures and flourishes. (This is in stark opposition to Monder shredding without appearing to move at all. At least from our vantage point; he could’ve been making silly faces toward the other half of the crowd.)
Another treat for the eyes was the band’s matching headwear. Each member sported a beanie, perhaps in an attempt to evoke the Minnesota winters of the founders’ childhood. Their hairlines were left to the imagination.
Ultimately, this was a show about how cool it is to have lifelong friends, and I was so happy I got to see it with Lena, who has known me since I was 14!
